About The Cookie Caterer™
Our decadent cookies are made from scratch and handcrafted with love. We take pride in providing you with the absolute BEST cookies you’ll ever eat.
When you walk into our store you instantly smell
the divine aroma of our FRESHLY baked cookies.
No transportation? No Problem! We deliver anywhere in New Providence AND we ship to the family islands!
“Great cookies! Great service! What more can I say? My husband can’t get enough and they had my 5 year old sneaking to watsapp at 6am about how good the cookies are! Hands down the best cookies we’ve ever had!”
Ellanna Carey Minus
“I’ve been ordering cookies from The Cookie Caterer for the past 2 years now. Every time I order I’m pleased with the cookies. They also have excellent customer service and I would recommend to anyone interested in a sweet treat!”
“Ohhh myyyy word!!! Best cookies I’ve EVER tasted in my life. I’ve been around the world serving in the military and never once had something so delicious! Extremely friendly and quick service. .delivered the next day to Eleuthera! You are definitely blessed continue to keep it up!!!! Thank you again, you made my daughters day!!!!”